The Supreme Court recently upheld the dismissal of Lieutenant Samuel Kamalesan from the Indian Army, asserting that his refusal to enter a temple's sanctum sanctorum constituted a severe breach of military discipline. The case emphasizes the Army's secular ethos and the expectations placed upon service members to uphold this principle. Initiated in 2017, Kamalesan's military career was marred by controversy when he declined to participate in religious practices associated with other faiths, citing personal beliefs. His dismissal, initially carried out by the Army, was later supported by the Delhi High Court in 2021, which determined that his actions represented disobedience to lawful commands.
Supreme Court Upholds Dismissal of Army Officer Over Religious Dispute
India Today •
Image source: India Today website
The Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal of Lieutenant Samuel Kamalesan from the Army for refusing to enter a temple, highlighting the importance of discipline and secularism within military ranks. Despite his argument rooted in religious beliefs, the court ruled that his conduct undermined the unity and morale of the troops, leading to a reaffirmation of the Army's standards regarding religious practices. The ruling illustrates the balance between individual religious rights and organizational discipline in the armed forces.